QUANTITY, where one tries to be as
informative as one possibly can, and gives as much information as is needed,
and no more.
QUALITY, where one tries to be truthful,
and does not give information that is false or that is not supported by
evidence.
RELATION,
where one tries to be relevant, and says things that are pertinent to the
discussion.
MANNER, when one tries to be as clear,
as brief, and as orderly as one can in what one says, and where one avoids
obscurity and ambiguity.
We can
VIOLATE them
We can FLOUT them
If we
FLOUT a maxim, we break it in a FLAGRANT way, so that it is obvious to all
concerned that it has been broken. Grice distinguishes what he calls 'sentence
meaning' from 'utterer's meaning' and he refers to an utterer's meaning indicated
through a flout as an IMPLICATURE. So the implicate is what we have been
referring to so far as the 'extra meaning'.
htis
means that we break the maxims so that other people do not know. If we violate
the maxim of quality, we lie. If we violate the maxim of quantity by not giving
enough information, if someone finds out we can be accused of 'being economical
with the truth', another deceit. Violating the maxims is similar to breaking
them 'illegally', just as people who steal are guilty of breaking the law. As
with laws, some maxim violations can be worse than others. Lying in a court of
law is disapproved, but 'white lies' are small lies to keep the social peace
and are often thought as acceptable.
No comments:
Post a Comment